“Who Is My Neighbor?” A Response to Dale Partridge on the Good Samaritan and What the Church Has Always Said

November 12–14, 2026 was the New Christian Right (NXR) conference at the Irving Convention Center near Dallas, hosted by Joel Webbon, “Christ Is King: America After Trump.” Dale Partridge gave a speech, “Love Your Neighbor by Deporting Him,” arguing that neighbor-love is “ordered affection…within the bonds of people and place, and land.” When challenged, he claimed on X that his reading of the Good Samaritan (Luke 10:25–37) was the view of “almost every Theologian prior to 1900.” It’s not. Not even close. From Origen, Ambrose, Augustine, Cyril of Alexandria, and Theophylact of Ochrid to Calvin, Matthew Henry, Matthew Poole, John Gill, and the Dutch Reformed exegete Seakle Greijdanus, the church has answered “Who is my neighbor?” the same way: every person in need whom God puts in your path.


Who is Dale Partridge?

He pastors a church in Prescott, Arizona, is the president of Relearn.org, and is the founder of Reformation Seminary. As host of the American Glory podcast, he describes himself as an advocate for Christian Nationalism and a theology of race

His public identity has shifted often. He first came to prominence as a business and lifestyle author with his 2015 People Over Profit: Break the System, Live with Purpose, Be More Successful and his 2017 Launch Your Dream: A 30-Day Plan for Turning Your Passion into Your Profession. He then promoted house churches and taught Christians to “unlearn church,” before identifying as a Presbyterian. Now he describes himself as “Anglican.” At this month’s conference, he shared the bill with Nick Fuentes.

He has also had to correct the record about his own credentials. In his own published statements, he has acknowledged “misleading language,” “carelessness,” and “poor way[s] to communicate” regarding his education and credentials. He has confessed to “sinful exaggerations” and “deception.” As he observes, for an entrepreneur and marketer the “greatest temptation often involves exaggeration and embellishment…when the brand is you.” Therein lies the problem for a man without accountability and oversight, which submission to a Reformed church polity of a consistory, classis, and synod would’ve brought him (see my A Well-Ordered Church: Laying a Foundation for a Vibrant Church [Evangelical Press, 2015]).

His formal theological training is a graduate certificate from Western Seminary. He is now a seminary president, and as of October 29, 2025, King’s Way Academy listed him as a “Professor of History”. That makes it all the more important to test his historical claims against the sources.

What Dale Partridge Said

In his speech, Partridge turns Jesus’s parable of the good or merciful Samaritan (Luke 10:25–37) upside down, applying it against H-1B Indians, Somali Muslim women, and non-“heritage Americans.” Christians can and should debate immigration policy. If you don’t like our policies, work to change them; that’s called being an American. But the question before us isn’t policy. It’s what Jesus meant.

I will focus on his central claims:

“Are the 40 H-1B Indians who moved into your housing complex your neighbors?” Yes, whether you like the policy that brought them here or not.

“The answer to both these questions [including “peers” language in the Constitution] historically is certainly no.” As we’ll see, the church’s historic answer is the opposite.

“So, as an American, the Hindu, on our welfare system, who is defrauding our country through hospice scams, is not my neighbor in the same way that the Heritage American is. The Muslim man who relocated their family specifically to claim my home and claim my land, and his religion to crusade over my people is not my neighbor in the same way that the Heritage American that has been here, who has relatives in the Civil War. These people are strangers, if you want to use biblical terms at the very least, but more often than not, they are actually my enemy. Now, you might say, ‘Dale, Jesus says to love your enemies as well.’ To which I say yes. But again, if we get into categories, what is an enemy?”

He then asks,

“What is a neighbor? …Neighborly love is the positive duty of ordered affection, and protection within the bonds of people and place, and land. It’s what is required of heritage Americans to give to other heritage Americans. God calls us to love everyone, but again, he doesn’t call us to love everyone equally in the same way. The loves are different for a wife and for a child, and for a citizen [notice the eisegesis of inserting political categories into a string of biblical texts], and for a sojourner, and for a stranger, and the love for enemy. These are real categories of love, but they are very different, and we don’t want to fall into the egalitarian framework, or everything is the same.”

Note that Partridge does say, “God calls us to love everyone.” But watch what he does with it. Everyone gets “love,” but only heritage Americans get neighbor-love. “Strangers” like Hindus and Muslims become “enemies.” In his X reply he dropped the pretense altogether: the parable “was not to treat everybody like a neighbor.” That is the claim I’m going to test against the church’s history.

Later in the speech, he says something that undercuts his own premise: “We have to remember that these verses, these love your neighbor, there are no distinctions.” Exactly. But then he says, “They were written in a world that is completely opposite to ours. It’s a world where visual [?], and national, and linguistic, and sexual and racial distinctions were so sharp and so hostile. I mean, think about this for a second. Jews refuse to help dying Samaritans because they were considered half-breed heretics”. “White Gentiles [not an ancient category] were considered unclean animals by the Jews. Often still are. Romans called Jews the enemies of all mankind”. “Greeks viewed black skin as an omen connected to death. Slaves were worthless people. Husbands were legally allowed to kill their children and their wives. Bloodlines were everything” [the very bloodlines that “Heritage American” language revives]. “The distinctions were so sharp”. “It is a completely opposite world to the world that we live in today”. “In other words, ethnic and cultural prejudice, real, genuine, and often sinful prejudice was just a fact of life in the biblical world”. “This is the context that we need to read into these passages” [but we read passages in their context; we don’t read context into them].

The exegetical point I want to focus on is that love of neighbor does not mean everyone, according to Partridge. In a subsequent reply on X, here’s what he said:

“The purpose of the parable [of the good or merciful Samaritan] was to teach the Jews that Samaritans were ‘neighbors.’ And they were ‘neighbors’ because they were in covenant with the Jews through circumcision. It was not to treat everybody like a neighbor. This is the physician [sic] of almost every Theologian prior to 1900. Study up, pal.”

So, let’s take his advice and study up.

Were the Samaritans “in Covenant with the Jews through Circumcision”?

Let’s start with Scripture. Yes, the Samaritans circumcised. Their remnant still does today in Kiryat Luza, near Mt. Gerazim, south of Nablus in the West Bank, and in Holon, near Tel Aviv in Israel. The Gospels don’t treat that as membership in Israel’s covenant. When a Samaritan leper came back to give thanks, Jesus called him “this foreigner” (allogenēs; Luke 17:18). When he first sent out the Twelve, he said, “Go nowhere among the Gentiles and enter no town of the Samaritans” (Matt. 10:5). Samaritans were considered outsiders, not insiders. The Samaritan woman was stunned that a Jew would ask her for a drink, “for Jews have no dealings with Samaritans” (John 4:9). Jesus tells her plainly, “You worship what you do not know” (John 4:22). And one chapter before our parable, James and John wanted to call down fire on a Samaritan village; Jesus “turned and rebuked them” (Luke 9:52–55). Luke wants you to read the Good Samaritan with that rebuke still ringing in your ears. And when the gospel went out after Pentecost, it was to Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria, and the ends of the earth (Acts 1:8).

In the parable itself, the man in the ditch has no ethnicity or religion. He’s just “a man” (anthrōpos tis; v. 30). Jesus didn’t answer the lawyer’s question on the lawyer’s terms. He turned it around: “Which of these three, do you think, proved to be a neighbor to the man who fell among the robbers?” (v. 36). The question isn’t which category of person qualifies for my love. It’s whether I will become a neighbor to whoever is bleeding in front of me (see Greijdanus below).

Here’s the irony. If neighbor-love really ran along covenant lines, Partridge’s neighbors would be the baptized, not the “heritage.” The Indian Christian on an H-1B visa, the baptized Somali convert, and the Honduran Catholic would have a stronger claim on him than the unbaptized fifth-generation unbeliever whose great-great-grandfather fought in the Civil War. Partridge’s covenant argument doesn’t get him to “Heritage Americans.” It gets him to the church, the one nation on earth called “holy” (ethnos hagion; 1 Pet. 2:9).

Not one theologian before 1900 below grounds the Samaritan’s neighborliness in circumcision. Not one.

Seakle Greijdanus on Luke 10:25–37

I want to begin with Seakle Greijdanus. He was professor of New Testament at the Theological School in Kampen. His commentary Het Evangelie naar Lucas was published in 1955 in the Korte Verklaring der Heilige Schrift by J.H. Kok in Kampen—well beyond the 60-year cutoff date Partridge offers in his address for everyone believing what he believes (his X reply says 1900). Greijdanus’s comments are in volume 1:275–83. I find his exegesis masterful. I’ll give a few rough translations of my own, below.

First, he called this “the parable of the merciful Samaritan” (de gelijkenis van den barmhartigen Samaritaan), tying it to the lawyer’s own words in verse 37: “The one who showed him mercy” (barmhartigheid).

Second, as Greijdanus asked, “But then again, who was his neighbor?” He summarized what that meant to a first-century Jew (more on this below): “The Jews did not understand ‘neighbor’ to mean any fellow human being with whom they came into interaction or contact in any way, but rather a fellow Jew. And the Pharisees had narrowed it down even further to their fellow Pharisees. From the commandment to love one’s neighbor, they had deduced: therefore, hate the enemy, Matt. 5:43” (pp. 279–80; emphasis mine). Sounds like the Jews (the irony!) had an ordered affection within the bonds of people, place, and land kind of like heritage Americans have for other heritage Americans. In fact, Greijdanus pointed out that the Samaritan “was not a fellow countryman of this unfortunate man, as the priest and Levite presumably were, but rather one of the people whom the Jews hated, and who himself hated the Jews” (p. 281). On Partridge’s logic, Jews and Samaritans had their loves in order.

Third, why did the Samaritan, then, stop? “This is not a matter of theoretical musings, but of a calling from God, and of fulfilling that calling….The priest and Levite should have acted in the same way. They had neglected their calling. This Samaritan, however, had fulfilled it, and had felt himself to be a neighbor to this unfortunate man and proved it through his actions” (p. 282).

Fourth, in Jesus’s application, the lawyer “could not bring himself to say simply: ‘The Samaritan’” because of pride and hostility (p. 282). When the lawyer says, “The one who showed him mercy” (Luke 10:37), this was a literary device called a “circumlocution” (omschrijving; p. 282). But Jesus had masterfully drawn this out of the lawyer, who, Greijdanus said, “expresses precisely what the real issue was and what matters most: to offer help where it is needed, to show compassion where it is required” (p. 282). And here’s the kicker: this help and compassion was to be shown “toward whomever and under whatever circumstances. Being a neighbor is not a relationship about receiving, but about giving—money, help, goods—wherever and however much is needed. The question is not: ‘Who must help me?’ but rather, ‘Whom must I help?’” (p. 282).

Fifth, to the lawyer’s question “Who is my neighbor?” Greijdanus brought Jesus’s parable home: “the answer is: every wretched or needy person whom God causes you to meet and places on your path” (pp. 282–83).

Here’s the verdict of this Dutch Reformed exegete. The lawyer came to Jesus with the rabbinic definition of neighbor in hand: a fellow Jew, a fellow Pharisee, and enemies you were free to hate. Jesus blew this definition up by making a hated, “half-breed” Samaritan the hero. This forced the lawyer to eat his own question. So, the question isn’t, “Who must help me?” but, “Whom must I help?” Greijdanus’s answer: whomever God places on your path, under whatever circumstances. Not circumcision nor ordered affection within the bonds of people, place, and land.

Some will wave Greijdanus off as a twentieth-century voice of the “post-war consensus.” Fine. Let’s go back before 1900. Way back.

What the Church Fathers Said about the Good Samaritan

Origen

Origen interpreted the Good Samaritan as Jesus Christ. At the end of his exposition, he gave his congregation the application:

Truly was this Guardian of souls, Who had shown compassion to him who fell among robbers, closer to him than the Law and the Prophets; showing Himself a neighbour not only in name but in deed. From the words of Christ that now follow it is possible therefore for us to imitate Christ, to have compassion on those who have fallen among robbers, to draw near them, to bind their wounds, pouring in oil and wine, to place them upon our own beast, and bear their burthens. And so the Son of God, exhorting us to like good works, says, not so much to the lawyer as to us also; Go; and do thou in like manner. And if we do in like manner, we shall come to the possession of eternal life in Christ Jesus, to Whom be glory and honour for ever and ever. Amen.

Ambrose

Similarly, Ambrose of Milan took an allegorical approach to see Jesus as the Samaritan. Like Origen, he concluded with an exhortation to his people:

Since, then, we have no better neighbour (proximus) than He who has healed our wounds, let us love Him both as our Lord and as our nearest and dearest (proximum). For what can be nearer (proximum) to its members than the head? We should also love those who imitate Christ; we should love those who bond with the poor and have compassion on their poverty. It is not relationship of blood that makes a person close (proximum), but mercy. For mercy is like nature (naturam). Nothing is more natural (naturam) than to come to the help of those who have our nature (naturae). [Commentary of Saint Ambrose on the Gospel according to Saint Luke, 7.84, trans. Íde M. Ní Riain (Dublin: Halcyon Press, in association with Elo Publications, 2001), 215.]

Jesus is our neighbor/nearest to us (proximus…proximum). No one is nearer to us as a neighbor than our Lord. He loved us, and this is why we should love in turn. Thus, in utter distinction from the “race realists” like Partridge, Ambrose grounded our love in this: Non enim cognatio facit proximum, sed misericordia, “It is not relationship of blood (or ‘kinship’ in M.F. Toal’s translation) that makes a person close, but mercy.” Why? Quia misericordia secundum naturam, “Because mercy is according to nature.” In fact, nihil enim tam secundum naturam quam iuvare consortem naturae, “For nothing is so natural (“according to nature”) as to help a fellow member/partner of nature.” St. Ambrose grounds the Christian duty of loving neighbor in our common human nature, not in ethnicity, nationality, or even “because they were in covenant with the Jews through circumcision.” (Latin text)

Augustine

If any church father could be claimed for Partridge’s view, it’s Augustine. He’s the source of the ordo amoris (see below under Calvin) the “order of love,” that Partridge appeals to. What did Augustine actually say about the Good Samaritan in light of “ordered love”?

In On Christian Doctrine, after laying out “the order of love,” Augustine said that “every man is to be loved as a man (there’s Ambrose’s nature) for God’s sake” (1.27.28). Then he explains how the order works: “all men are to be loved equally. But since you cannot do good to all, you are to pay special regard to those who, by the accidents of time, or place, or circumstance, are brought into closer connection with you” (1.28.29). Did you catch that? Love is equal. What gets ordered is help, because we’re finite. And the order is set by time, place, and circumstance, not blood and soil. Augustine even says that when two people have an equal claim on you and you can only help one, you might as well draw lots. The “desire” of the Christian is that “all join with us in loving God, and all the assistance that we either give them or accept from them should tend to that one end” (1.29.30). Love of neighbor is evangelistic. “Hence it is that we love even our enemies” (1.29.30). What about Dale’s enemies?

“For we do not fear them, seeing they cannot take away from us what we love; but we pity them rather, because the more they hate us the more are they separated from Him whom we love. For if they would turn to Him, they must of necessity love Him as the supreme good, and love us too as partakers with them in so great a blessing” (1.29.30).

Then he turns to the parable. Jesus “showed him that nobody was neighbor to this man except him who took pity upon him and came forward to relieve and care for him” (1.30.31). No one is excepted: “he is our neighbor whom it is our duty to help in his need, or whom it would be our duty to help if he were in need” (1.30.31). Again, listen to these words in the context of Partridge’s speech and ask who is on the side of the church’s historic teaching?: “who does not see that no exception is made of any one as a person to whom the offices of mercy may be denied when our Lord extends the rule even to our enemies? ‘Love your enemies, do good to them that hate you’” (1.30.31). Augustine concluded with the assertion that everyone is my neighbor. Listen to how he argues:

“Whoever then supposes that the apostle did not embrace every man in this precept, is compelled to admit, what is at once most absurd and most pernicious, that the apostle thought it no sin, if a man were not a Christian or were an enemy, to commit adultery with his wife, or to kill him, or to covet his goods. And as nobody but a fool would say this, it is clear that every man is to be considered our neighbor, because we are to work no ill to any man.” (1.30.32).

The father of ordo amoris used the Good Samaritan to teach the opposite of Partridge’s ordo amoris.

Cyril of Alexandria and Theophylact of Ochrid (via Aquinas’s Catena Aurea)

Next up are two fathers mediated via Thomas’s Catena Aurea, a medieval commentary on Scripture in the form of a “golden chain” of church fathers. What is striking from the early church father Cyril of Alexandria’s comment is the application: “for he who loves not his brother whom he sees, cannot love God whom he does not see” (vol. 3, part 1, 370). This is a warning directly to your heart. Aquinas then quotes the medieval Byzantine bishop Theophylact of Ochrid (ca. 1050–after 1107):

“Now our Saviour defines a neighbor not in respect of actions or honour, but […wait for it…] of nature; as if He says, Think not that because thou art righteous thou hast no neighbor, for all who partake of the same nature are thy neighbours. Be thou also their neighbor, not in place, but in affection and solicitude for them.”

There it is again: the ground of our loving neighbor is common nature; and this also means neighbor extends to all with human nature—whether you like them or not.

So, according to the Fathers, “Who is my neighbor?” First of all, Christ, the true Samaritan who drew near to us while we lay half dead in the ditch. Because we are to imitate him, whoever lies in the ditch now: have compassion on the fallen; draw near as a neighbor to the poor. It’s not kinship that makes a neighbor, but mercy. This is so important with the rise of so-called “Kinism” or “race realism.” This is a modern racial separatist ideology that speaks of preserving one’s own people as a divine duty. This means God intends distinct racial groups to preserve themselves through same-ethnicity marriage, homogeneous communities, and separate nations. Thus, some say interracial marriage is sinful. You’ll hear it coded as “ordered loves,” “ethnic preservation,” “natural affection,” or a preference for living among one’s own people.

All who share our nature are our neighbors. The warning is if you don’t love those you can see, how can you claim to love the God you can’t? This is Christian ethics and discipleship 101. This is the path on which we will one day possess eternal life in Christ. Not one Father grounded their answer in blood or soil.

This isn’t “almost every Theologian prior to 1900,” but it’s a fair sample from the third to eleventh centuries of the church.

Someone might object that the fathers were too allegorical, too Greek, too Catholic. So, let’s turn to the tradition Partridge claims as his own, and to the Reformer who had no patience for allegory.

John Calvin on “Who Is My Neighbor?”

In his commentary on the Good Samaritan, John Calvin speaks of the second great commandment to love our neighbors as depending on the first. His reason? “For, since every man is devoted to himself, there will never be true charity towards neighbors, unless where the love of God reigns.” Then he explains the kind of love fallen human beings have: “for it is a mercenary love which the children of the world entertain for each other, because every one of them has regard to his own advantage.” Think again of Partridge’s definition: “Neighborly love is the positive duty of ordered affection, and protection within the bonds of people and place, and land. It’s what is required of heritage Americans to give to other heritage Americans.” In other words, selfish love, bent in on itself, as Luther, channeling Augustine, described: incurvatus in se (Lectures on Romans 5:4, 6:6, 8:3; Luther’s Works 25:291, 313, 345). Calvin continued: “On the other hand, it is impossible for the love of God to reign without producing brotherly kindness among men.” A neighbor-love that flows only to our own is what Calvin calls “mercenary love” (mercenarius amor). It’s “hired” love: it loves for what it gets back.

Then Calvin goes directly at, and against, the Roman Catholic scholastic version of ordo amoris, “the order of loves,” that Partridge echoes:

“Again, when Moses commanded us to love our neighbors as ourselves, he did not intend to put the love of ourselves in the first place, so that a man may first love himself and then love his neighbors; as the sophists of the Sorbonne are wont to cavil, that a rule must always go before what it regulates.”

This is the scholastic axiom traced from Augustine through Aquinas into our Reformed tradition that since a rule (regula) is ontologically prior and superior to the thing it regulates (regulatum), the command “love your neighbor as yourself” means self-love serves as the “rule” for loving others. Therefore, rightly ordered love starts with God, of course, but horizontally it legitimately is directed towards self first and more before it reaches neighbor. Kinists then reason that love goes out in concentric, ever-widening circles: self, family (kin), church, nation, etc. Even the late Pope Francis saw through it:

Christian love is not a concentric expansion of interests that little by little extend to other persons and groups. In other words: the human person is not a mere individual, relatively expansive, with some philanthropic feelings! The human person is a subject with dignity who, through the constitutive relationship with all, especially with the poorest, can gradually mature in his identity and vocation. The true ordo amoris that must be promoted is that which we discover by meditating constantly on the parable of the “Good Samaritan” (cf. Lk 10:25-37), that is, by meditating on the love that builds a fraternity open to all, without exception.

Ordo amoris has been used to create a hierarchy of loves in which the conclusion is that we do not need to extend that love to “others” outside our circles. Think immigrants and refugees, the very Indians, Somalis, Hindus, and Muslims whom Partridge singled out.

With Calvin we can acknowledge that, of course, Christian love has different practical applications within the relationships we have, at the same time as the all-encompassing command of Christ to love everyone without exception. In Institutes, 2.8.55, he wrote: 

“I deny not that the closer the relation the more frequent our offices of kindness should be. For the condition of humanity requires that there be more duties in common between those who are more nearly connected by the ties of relationship, or friendship, or neighborhood.”

Obviously, my love for my children causes me to seek to provide food and shelter for them and not for everyone in all places. Ordo amoris doesn’t limit love, as it is warped in Christian Nationalist and Kinist minds: “But I say that the whole human race, without exception, are to be embraced with one feeling of charity” (Institutes, 2.8.55). If left to our own selfish love, we will base affection on merit and consider “the other” unworthy of our “rightly ordered love.” “But Scripture subjoins a most excellent reason, when it tells us that we are not to look to what men in themselves deserve, but to attend to the image of God, which exists in all, and to which we owe all honour and love.” (Institutes, 3.7.6). The imago Dei, or “nature” as the Fathers above said, is the ground of our common humanity and thus love.

Returning to Luke 10:30, Calvin said, “Christ might have stated simply, that the word neighbor extends indiscriminately to every man, because the whole human race is united by a sacred bond of fellowship.” He actually deals with Partridge’s objection: why didn’t God simply say, “Love everyone”? Calvin: “The commandment would have run more clearly thus: Love every man as thyself.” Here’s why he didn’t: “But as men are blinded by their pride, so that every man is satisfied with himself, scarcely deigns to admit others to an equal rank, and withholds from them the duties he owes them, the Lord purposely declares that all are neighbors that the very relationship may produce mutual love. To make any person our neighbor, therefore, it is enough that he be a man; for it is not in our power to blot out our common nature.” There’s that patristic emphasis again.

Calvin deals with another false notion, that it’s a general maxim among men “that no man is our neighbor unless he is our friend.” If Jesus hadn’t dealt with the lawyer in the way he did, “he would never have made an explicit acknowledgment, that under the word neighbor all men are included, which the comparison brought forward forces him to confess.” Listen to this: “The general truth conveyed is, that the greatest stranger is our neighbor, because God has bound all men together, for the purpose of assisting each other.” In this parable, “the chief design is to show that the neighborhood…is not confined to friends or relatives, but extends to the whole human race.”

Calvin said Christ’s proof of this is to compare a Samaritan to a priest and a Levite. “It is well known what deadly hatred the Jews bore to the Samaritans, so that, notwithstanding their living close beside them, they were always at the greatest variance.” But in Jesus’s parable, the Jewish inhabitant of Jericho is not helped by his fellow Jewish priest or Levite, but by a Samaritan. “For here, as in a mirror, we behold that common relationship of men, which the scribes endeavored to blot out by their wicked sophistry; and the compassion, which an enemy showed to a Jew, demonstrates that the guidance and teaching of nature are sufficient to show that man was created for the sake of man. Hence it is inferred that there is a mutual obligation between all men.”

Calvin dismissed allegory but still landed where Origen and Ambrose did (on Luke 10:30). Neighbor “extends indiscriminately to every man.” “The greatest stranger is our neighbor.” The neighborhood that obligates us “extends to the whole human race.” He said this, granting the very point Partridge relies on: the closer the relation, “the more frequent our offices of kindness should be.” For Calvin, ordered love governs how we help, not whether someone counts as our neighbor. Partridge’s distinction is closer to the Sorbonists; Calvin rejected it.

But Calvin was a French refugee in Geneva who welcomed other refugees into the city. Partridge’s professed heritage is Anglo-Protestant, so let’s cross the Channel.

English Dissenters on the Good Samaritan

Matthew Henry

One of the most widely known and available post-Reformation English commentaries on the Bible is Matthew Henry’s (and a few who helped finish it after his death). In his commentary on the parable of the Good Samaritan, he leads with, “We must wish well to all and ill to none; must do all the good we can in the world and no hurt, and must fix it as a rule to ourselves to do to others as we would they should do to us; and this is to love our neighbour as ourselves.” Pretty standard second great commandment fare.

Henry then explains, “what was the corrupt notion of the Jewish teachers in this matter.” He followed the work of the eminent Hebraist of the age and Westminster Assembly divine, John Lightfoot (1602–75), whose Horae Hebraicae et Talmudicae was a verse-by-verse commentary on the New Testament from the Talmud and the rabbis. According to Lightfoot’s research into the rabbis, “You shall love your neighbor” did not include Gentiles, because “neighbor” included “those only that are of our own nation and religion.” In other words, “ordered affection…within the bonds of people and place, and land.” Israelites were exempt from the death penalty for killing Gentiles since they weren’t neighbors and “if they saw a Gentile in danger of death, they thought themselves under no obligation to help to save his life.” Henry called these ideas “wicked inferences…draw[n] from that holy covenant of peculiarity by which God had distinguished them,” which was an abuse and ground for their forfeiture of the favors of the covenant. Here’s the irony: Partridge’s reading lines up with the rabbis whom our older commentators refuted, not with the commentators themselves. The very ethnocentric exclusivity of rabbinic Judaism he criticizes is his position.

The Irony of Whom We Are to Love

The rabbis, via Matthew Henry

“those only that are of our own nation and religion”

Dale Partridge, 2026

“ordered affection … within the bonds of people and place, and land”


In the parable, though, “Christ corrected this inhuman notion” to teach “that whomsoever we have need to receive kindness from, and find ready to show us the kindness we need, we cannot but look upon as our neighbour…though they be not of our own nation and religion.” Thus in the parable, “When [the Samaritan] saw [the Jew] he had compassion on him, and never took into consideration what country he was of.” Like the Fathers and Calvin before him, Henry commented: “Though he was a Jew, he was a man, and a man in misery, and the Samaritan has learned to honour all men; he knows not how soon this poor man's case may be his own, and therefore pities him, as he himself would desire and expect to be pitied in the like case.”

One thing Henry goes back to is the interpretation of Origen and Ambrose that saw the Good Samaritan as Christ. Henry allows it as a secondary application: “this parable is applicable to another purpose than that for which it was intended; and does excellently set forth the kindness and love of God our Saviour towards sinful miserable man.” Our Savior loves all (yes, in good Reformed scholastic fashion, we distinguish three senses; see my Grace Worth Fighting For); so must we: “Go, and do likewise” (Luke 10:37). This duty is “mutual and reciprocal…as is agreed in all contracts.” For Henry, this meant “show mercy to those that need thy help, and do it freely, and with concern and compassion, though they be not of thy own nation and thy own profession, or of thy own opinion and communion in religion.”

Matthew Poole

Another of the voluminous exegetes of the seventeenth century was Matthew Poole in his Annotations upon the Holy Bible. Like Henry, his followers completed the task. Volume 2 (London, 1685) contains the Annotations on Luke.

The reason the lawyer asked, “who is my neighbor?” was that “the Scribes and Pharisees… counted none their Neighbors, but their Friends, and benefactors, at least none but those that were of their own Nation or particular Sect, and had taught their People, that they might hate their enemies.”

Why did Jesus teach this parable? “It is certain that the Principal Scope of our Savior in this History, or Parable, was to convince the Lawyer, that every one is our Neighbor, to whom God offered us an opportunity of doing good, whether he be of our Nation, or Religion yea or no. Every object of our Mercy is our Neighbor, whom God requireth us to love as ourselves, this was quite contrary to the common Doctrine of the Scribes and Pharisees.”

John Gill

For my Baptist brothers and sisters, consider John Gill. Whom did the lawyer understand his neighbor to be? Gill describes the lawyer’s view, and it sounds a lot like Partridge’s: “for by his neighbour he meant only an Israelite; one of the same nation and religion with him.” Then Gill adds, “So the Jews commonly interpret the word neighbour, either of one that is related to them in nature, that is, near akin to them in blood (citing David Kimchi’s commentary on Psalm 15:3); or that professes the same religion as they do” (citing Moses of Coucy’s Sefer Mitzvot Gadol). Citing Maimonides in his Mishneh Torah, Hilkhot Rotzeach u-Shmirat Nefesh: “for they will not allow a Gentile, no, not even a proselyte of the gate to be a neighbour.” Gill does not beat around the bush: “This notion Christ opposes and disproves in the following parable, which is an answer to the lawyer’s question.”

Three English Dissenters, two Presbyterians and a Baptist, read the parable the same way as Calvin and before him the Fathers. “Every object of our Mercy is our Neighbor.” Show mercy “though they be not of thy own nation.” “This notion Christ opposes and disproves.” They even dug into rabbinic sources themselves and found the very definition of neighbor Partridge is advancing: only “those that are of our own nation and religion.” They found it and named it as the error Jesus told the parable to overturn.

Conclusion: A Light Argument Weighed and Found Wanting

Partridge told us his was the position of “almost every Theologian prior to 1900.” We’ve heard from Origen, Ambrose, Augustine, Cyril of Alexandria, and Theophylact of Ochrid (Byzantine Bulgaria); John Calvin; three English Dissenters and a Dutch Reformed exegete. Not one of them says the Samaritan was a neighbor because of circumcision. Not one says neighbor-love runs along the lines of blood and soil. Every one of them says the opposite.

Against that consensus stands a single post on X.

A Better Way than Racial Nationalism

But I don’t want to end with Partridge. I want to end with you, the young man who’s found something in this movement that you don’t find in your church: conviction, brotherhood, belonging, a heritage. Those are good desires produced in you by the Holy Spirit. This movement offers a counterfeit of each one.

You want a heritage? Here’s one. It runs from Origen and Cyril in Alexandria, Ambrose in Milan, and Augustine in Hippo, Theophylact in Ochrid, through Calvin in Geneva, to English Dissenters and Dutch professors. They are your fathers in the faith. Across seventeen centuries, in Greek, Latin, French, English, and Dutch, they all said the same thing: anyone in the ditch is your neighbor.

You want ordered love? Scripture has one: “As we have opportunity, let us do good to everyone, and especially to those who are of the household of faith” (Gal. 6:10). Notice the words: everyone (pantas), and especially (malista). The Bible’s order of love has an “especially.” It never has an “only.” Its inner circle is drawn by faith, not by blood. Of course, you must provide for your own household first (1 Tim. 5:8) and the household of faith (tous oikeious tēs pisteōs). You can’t feed the world before you feed your kids. But the needy person God puts in your path doesn’t stop being your neighbor because of his passport, skin color, accent, religion, or lack thereof.

You can argue all you want about immigration policy. That’s the birthright of citizenship in a constitutional republic. You can think the H-1B program is horrendous policy and that welfare fraud should lead to deportation. Christian: get involved in civic politics. But the parable doesn’t write immigration law. Because it’s the Word of the Lord, it does take away your right to ask whether the person in front of you qualifies for your love. That’s non-negotiable.

You want conviction? Find a church whose ministers of the Word and sacraments are trained, called, ordained, accountable: men who have signed their names, and staked their honor, to teach and defend the ancient creeds and centuries-old confessions sealed with the blood of martyrs. Guido de Brès wrote the Belgic Confession, then was hanged for his faith in 1567. That’s conviction. You don’t need the latest podcast outrage. You need a pastor who answers to a body bigger than his own microphone.

You want belonging? Join a confessional church where the very first question and answer of its Catechism says: “I am not my own, but belong—body and soul, in life and in death—to my faithful Savior Jesus Christ” (Heidelberg Catechism, Q&A 1). Before you belong to a people or place, you belong to him. And if you belong to him, you belong with everyone he has bought.

You want brotherhood? Come to a confessional church this Lord’s Day, where baptismal water is thicker than blood and the Holy Communion Table is approached by those who trace their families to Seoul, Beijing, and Jakarta; Tehran, Mosul, and Beirut; Kampala, Lagos, and Pretoria; Santiago, Mexico City, and Grand Rapids via Dordrecht. They don’t share a bloodline. They share a Savior, water on their heads, one loaf, and one cup. “We who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Cor. 10:17).

Then become a “living member” of such a church (Heidelberg, Q&A 54), and use your gifts “readily and cheerfully” to enrich its singles and couples, families, widows, orphans (Heidelberg, Q&A 55). And be enriched in return. Let godly elders learn your name and develop mentoring relationships with you. Let them visit you in your home and hold you accountable for the glory of God. Watch the deacons’ example, stirring you up to do what the Samaritan did: bind up wounds and pay the innkeeper.

Then have your horizon expanded. That congregation doesn’t stand alone. It’s bound together with others in a classis and a synod, with sister churches across this continent in the North American Presbyterian and Reformed Council, and with churches on every continent in the International Conference of Reformed Churches. It belongs to the one true church that the Son of God gathers “out of the entire human race” (Heidelberg, Q&A 54), the people the eternal Son became flesh to redeem a people “from every people, tribe, nation, and language” (Canons of Dort, 2.8). The church “is not confined, bound, or limited to a certain place or certain persons” but is “spread and dispersed throughout the entire world” (Belgic Confession, art. 27).,

The church is a family. You don’t have to be “heritage” anything to be one of its “adopted children…by grace for the sake of Christ” (Heidelberg, Q&A 33).

Above all, remember who the true Good Samaritan is. The Fathers saw him: we were the man in the ditch, stripped, beaten, and half dead. The One whose presence stooped down to us was the One we despised. The Son of God crossed every line that mattered to us, bound up our wounds at the cost of his own blood, and paid our bill in full. He “made from one man every nation of mankind” (ex henos pan ethnos anthrōpōn; Acts 17:26), or, as the Textus Receptus reads, “of one blood” (haimatos). He’s gathering a people “from every tribe and from [every] language and from [every] people and from [every] nation” (Rev. 5:9 cf. 7:9; my translation). This people is his “kingdom” (Rev. 1:6) and “holy nation” (ethnos hagion; 1 Pet. 2:9) within the kingdoms and nations of this world. In this kingdom and nation “there is neither Jew nor Greek” (Gal. 3:28), because he “has made us both one and has broken down in his flesh the dividing wall of hostility” (Eph. 2:14).

And one day you’ll see them all, together as “a great multitude that no one could number, from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages, standing before the throne and before the Lamb,” crying with one voice, “Salvation belongs to our God who sits on the throne, and to the Lamb!” (Rev. 7:9–10). None will be there because of whose blood runs in their veins. Every one of them will be there because they “washed their robes and made them white in the blood of the Lamb” (Rev. 7:14). That’s not the end of your heritage. It is your inheritance: “imperishable, undefiled, and unfading, kept in heaven for you” (1 Pet. 1:4).

That’s the Christ who is King. He’s not a slogan for a conference. He’s the Samaritan who stopped for you.

Go, and do likewise.


Daniel R. Hyde (PhD, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) is the founding pastor of Oceanside United Reformed Church in Carlsbad, CA. He is the author of many books including Welcome to a Reformed Church: A Guide for Pilgrims (Ligonier) and Grace Worth Fighting For: Recapturing the Vision of God’s Grace in the Canons of Dort (Davenant, 2019).

Frequently Asked Questions


© 2026 Daniel R. Hyde. Permission is granted to reprint this article in full, unaltered, for non-commercial use, provided the attribution below is included and links to the original. For excerpts, translations, or commercial use, see Permissions.

To attribute: Daniel R. Hyde, "‘Who Is My Neighbor?’ A Response to Dale Partridge on the Good Samaritan and What the Church Has Always Said" https://www.danielrhyde.com/articles/who-is-my-neighbor-good-samaritan. Used by permission.

Next
Next

Sealed or Marked: What Is the Mark of the Beast in Revelation 13?